I’m Jessica, a wearer of many hats who is lucky enough to call Long Island, NY home. I am a devoted wife, avid animal lover, and all around goofball. I love the beach, music, cooking, and anything pink, and I am obsessed with traveling as much as I possibly can! Welcome to my online time capsule, I am so glad you are here :)  read more...

The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever!

The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever!
1.1K Flares Facebook 0 Google+ 0 Twitter 0 Pin It Share 1.1K StumbleUpon 1 Email -- 1.1K Flares ×

Halloween isn’t always about the cute and adorable, most of the time Halloween is quite scary!


With these recipes* for creepy treats, you can gross anyone out at the drop of a {witchs’} hat!


People will talk about these spooky Halloween ideas long after the party is over! The kitty litter cake grosses me out every time I look at the picture, which makes me want to try out the recipe even more 🙂 Are you big on Halloween in your family? Would you ever dare try one of these recipes ideas?


Ghoulish Breadsticks by Artisan Bread in 5

halloween drink recipes

A Bloody Mocktail by caroselloblog.com


Zombie Brains by rick a bam boo


Creepy Panna Cotta Eye by Kitchen Table Scraps


Human Torso Appetizer by Instructables.com


Meatloaf Zombies by Fabulously Frugal


Graveyard Taco Dip by chickabug blog


Bloody Bandaid Cookies by Noble Pig

Oreoelphia - Haddie Hinklebottom's sweet pet 10 copy

Sweet Cookies and Cream Cheese Rat by Hungry Happenings


Spooky Monster Eyes by Scattered Thoughts of a Crafty Mom


Kitty Litter Cake by Tablespoon.com

With these awesome Halloween recipes, you can gross out and disturb people instead of showering them with the same old boring food.


*this collection of recipes is meant to serve as a resource to help you find some Creepy Halloween food ideas from many talented bloggers! these photos belong to different bloggers and are not mine. i have compiled them here to create a visual index of their recipes.

jess signature

did you enjoy this post? let’s connect! follow me on twitter, instagram, and pinterest, or become a fan on facebook… thanks for reading <3

1.1K Flares Facebook 0 Google+ 0 Twitter 0 Pin It Share 1.1K StumbleUpon 1 Email -- 1.1K Flares ×

106 Responses to The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever!

  1. Omg love ittt!!!! These look like such fun Halloween foods!

  2. The eyeball panna cotta is genius!
    Ellen @ From Scratch recently posted…No Tricks, Just Treats – Homemade Candy CornMy Profile

  3. Cesar Diaz says:

    Love the ideas!!! The human torso is just great and simple to make.

  4. Lauren says:

    Wow — great ideas! My kids would probably love this, but I don’t know if I’d eat it!
    Lauren recently posted…Fall Cash GiveawayMy Profile

  5. Bonnie says:

    Those are some very clever and interesting Halloween foods. The litter box cake was too realistic for me. Haha Stopping by from the Home Matters Linky Party.
    Bonnie recently posted…Guest Co-Host Home Matters Linky PartyMy Profile

  6. Jamie says:

    I don’t celebrate Halloween so I won’t be making these, but the Band aide and the fingers have to be my favorite lol

  7. censie says:

    Great ideas! I have some up my sleeve too! I love this holiday!
    censie recently posted…Crunchy Bean Baked Mozzarella Stick #recipe and Snack Out Loud Prize Pack #giveawayMy Profile

  8. Jessica H. says:

    I love these ideas! The zombie brain Rice Krispie Treats are great!
    Jessica H. recently posted…Book of the Month: DIY Mason Jars + GiveawayMy Profile

  9. Ida says:

    These are amazing! I love the breadsticks and the graveyard dip! Such fun!
    Ida recently posted…Creation Celebration With Champions for Kids & FiskarsMy Profile

  10. Wow, these are great. I wouldn’t be able to do all of these but don’t know which ones to make first.

  11. That kitty litter cake is cracking me up. These all look like a lot of fun.

  12. Kirsten says:

    These ideas are all so fun! Better than the normal suggestions. Pinning for later.
    Kirsten recently posted…Where in the World Wednesday?My Profile

  13. Beth says:

    Great collection of posts! Love the Jennifer Lawrence gif at the end!!!

    I’m so addicted to anything and everything Halloween. And that litterbox cake makes me so queasy every time I see it. It just looks too much like the real thing!

    Beth at LWC Wonderland

  14. Now these are some creative ideas, I need to try them!
    Touristmeetstraveler recently posted…Adventure @UniversalORL Vivo Italian Kitchen and CityWalkMy Profile

  15. Jacqui says:

    These all look so spooky and yummy! Thank you for linking up to Party Time and we hope to see you again next week!
    Jacqui recently posted…Surprise! Gender Reveal CupcakesMy Profile

  16. tara pittman says:

    All great ideas. i need to make those finger things for my boys.
    tara pittman recently posted…ELPH Band and $125 Target Gift Card GiveawayMy Profile

  17. Oh these are some good ones. That torso especially. Would have liked to have been a fly on the wall while people were eating that one!
    Jill @ Do Try This at Home recently posted…DIY Elmo Halloween Costume: Sewing Machines Need Not ApplyMy Profile

  18. Amy G says:

    Those are some pretty gross treats! LOL One year we made Brain cupcakes…they looked pretty gross!

  19. Mary says:

    OMG so gross and creepy! The eye and the kitty litter cake really got to me–I bet they are both delish, though!
    Mary recently posted…Paw-sitively Fabulous: Henri Bendel x The College Prepster HB Puppy Love EventMy Profile

  20. Lizzie Lau says:

    What a terrific collection! I wish it was my turn to bring a snack to the preschool, I’d make those breadstick fingers or the rice krispie treat brains.
    I pinned it.
    Lizzie Lau recently posted…Book Review – Simple SMART & Happy by Kathy GottbergMy Profile

  21. Laurie WJN says:

    Oh my gosh these are hilarious, but I have to admit the bandaids gross me out.
    Laurie WJN recently posted…Book Review: Supernatural Hero by Eran GadotMy Profile

  22. Lux Ganzon says:

    Thank you for putting their labels as you were right, these are creepy food! But creative nonetheless.
    Lux Ganzon recently posted…Don’t Be SorryMy Profile

  23. WendyKate says:

    I LOVE the rat cake. So many great ideas.
    WendyKate recently posted…Love And A Dog * Your Daily Brain Vitamin v10.18.14My Profile

  24. Tahnie says:

    These are all fantastic! Great collection of ideas. Thanks so much for sharing. The kitty litter cake made me laugh out loud! 😉

    Stopping by from SITS and hope your Saturday is great!
    Tahnie recently posted…Organ Donation From The Perspective Of A 4 Year OldMy Profile

  25. Veyr creepy indeed. Thank you for sharing your post with Pin Worthy Wednesday this week. I’m posting this to out group board on Pinterest.
    Mrs. Mashed Up recently posted…Growing Up Music: Third Eye Blind Jumper Lyrics speak to suicideMy Profile

  26. Some very clever ways with food! Visiting from Pretty Pintastic Party!
    TERRI BURFIELD recently posted…Apple PieMy Profile

  27. These are great! The meatloaf zombies are TOO awesome.
    Sassy Dove | Makeup reviews with moxie recently posted…Getting Pampered with Facials at Redefine SpaMy Profile

  28. Tine says:

    Great listing! I especially liked the creepy fingers. I may just add that to our Halloween Night dinner menu!
    Tine recently posted…The Teal Pumpkin Project and Ten Ideas for Non-Candy Halloween TreatsMy Profile

  29. Allison B says:

    The finger and kitty litter cake gross me out. I don’t know why but I could never eat those two.
    Allison B recently posted…Confessions on FallMy Profile

  30. Paris says:

    Omg that kitty litter cake totally freaks me out

  31. Morgan says:

    I love these ideas! Thanks for sharing!
    Morgan recently posted…Two Spooky Halloween PrintablesMy Profile

  32. OMG – I think I just threw up a little – these things are so incredibly GROSS!!!
    Tove Stakkestad recently posted…Hunting and Gathering – Unifying Our FamilyMy Profile

  33. Robin Avidor says:

    Great ideas and I really needed some!
    Robin Avidor recently posted…Pamela Quinzi Returns To New York!My Profile

  34. Pam says:

    These are great. I love the fingers….very creepy.
    Pam recently posted…Cricut Card With Minnie and Mickey Mouse Die CutMy Profile

  35. Jessica Cook says:

    These are incredible! I’ve made the liter box cake before, it’s so yummy and sometimes freaks people out more than the actually scary stuff!

  36. That big panna cotta eyeball and the kitty litter box are both genius and pretty disgusting! I love it. You have the perfectly titled post for these!
    Miranda @ Cookie Dough & Oven Mitt recently posted…Sunday’s Recipe Wrap-up #13My Profile

  37. Adrian says:

    I LOVE scary and creepy! These recipes are right up my alley. Thank you for sharing this with us at last week’s Teach Me Tuesday Linky Party! We hope to see you there again tonight starting @ 9pm est:)
    Adrian recently posted…Are you on Tsu?My Profile

  38. There are so many great ideas here, I need to share them on my blog!
    Natural Organic Girl recently posted…The Benefits of Hyaluronic Acid, an Ingredient of Youthful Transitions Facial Care LineMy Profile

  39. Wow, those are creepy. Especially the eye ball! Gross!
    Mary {Raising Dick and Jane} recently posted…Hallowe’en at Greenfield Village is a Must See!My Profile

  40. These are great! Especially love the breadsticks 🙂 Thanks so much for linking up at the #homematters linky party! We hope to see you again this coming Wednesday!
    Kristen from The Road to Domestication recently posted…Five for Fall…PLUS Fall Home Tour!My Profile

  41. Eww, they are pretty creepy! I don’t know how many of them I could actually eat!
    Becky @ Disney in your Day recently posted…Make your own Belle Halloween costumeMy Profile

  42. becca says:

    Ok I admit it I am in love with these creepy foods. I would love to freak people out with them.
    becca recently posted…The Great Swap Reveal #Food #FashionMy Profile

  43. Jena says:

    Haha! Love this post! Those fingers are pretty creepy, and the mouse because I just hate mice!! Ewww
    Jena recently posted…Bossy: Being a Newbie Entrepreneur v.1My Profile

  44. Lauren says:

    Great round up! I am going to pin this one.. glad to connect on tasty tuesday! 🙂
    Lauren recently posted…Jake & the Never Land Pirates Battle for the Book & the Epic Battle Build Sweepstakes!My Profile

  45. Dee Mauser says:

    Halloween is my favorite holiday. It’s fun yet full of surprises and scares. The foods you listed are awesome!
    Dee Mauser recently posted…Hot Deal on Nora Roberts booksMy Profile

  46. Thanks for coming and linking up at #The Weekend Social. Please be sure to come back starting Thursdays at 9PM EST on KitchenDreaming.com ! I hope to see you there! Pinned

  47. These are so creepy! My husband loved them until we got to the kitty litter box. He said NO WAY! LOL
    ArIlington Mommy recently posted…Trick or Treating Alternatives in Arlington, TexasMy Profile

  48. Thanks for linking up with Savoring Saturdays! I love this post and can’t wait to try them all. Please add our link in case you are featured. Hope to see you next week! Stumbled and pinned!
    Ali the Skinny GF Chef recently posted…Savoring Saturdays #36My Profile

  49. I’m totally using the witch finger idea! Boo!!

  50. Yikes! You weren’t kidding when you said these were the creepiest Halloween foods ever! Thanks for sharing them with Hump Day Happenings.
    Jenna @ A Savory Feast recently posted…10 Tips for Growing your BlogMy Profile

  51. How awesomely GROSS! lol! Thank you for linking up with the #WeekendBlogHop

    Laura x x x
    My Life As A Mummy recently posted…Bath Time BattlesMy Profile

  52. I would like to invite you to attend our weekly #PureBlogLove Recipe and DIY craft party this week. Runs 8pm Thursdays-Sunday at midnight EST on http://www.themcallumsshamrockpatch.com. I hope to see you there! I adore your blog!
    Heidy @TheMccallumsShamrockPatch recently posted…#PureBlogLove Recipe and Craft Link Party #7My Profile

  53. Great collection! I am always looking for cool Halloween foods for my annual trick or treat party
    Jennifer Johnson recently posted…Fresh Cranberry Sauce with Orange ZestMy Profile

  54. Awesome list of Halloween food! love them so spooky, funny and yummy! This post will be featured at this weekends Snickerdoodle Sunday!
    Kristina & Millie recently posted…Snickerdoodle Sunday #52My Profile

  55. These are so clever! I think I might have to wait a couple of years to try them since it would probably scare my toddler! Hahaha.
    Rachel @ Third Stop on the Right recently posted…Finding Hope After Experiencing a MiscarriageMy Profile

  56. Otilia says:

    oh wow! I love the crispy brains!
    thank you for linking up with #FoodieFriday
    Otilia recently posted…Parenting Pin-It Party #75My Profile

  57. Scary stuff! I’m not even sure I could bring myself to eat any of them! 🙂 But they are all really cool, and I bet my kids would get a kick out of them! Thanks for sharing them with us at Foodie Fridays!! Hope we will see you again this week! Pinning!
    Michelle @ A Dish of Daily Life recently posted…Cannellini Bean and Parsley HummusMy Profile

  58. lisa says:

    You aren’t kidding! Some of that looks so creepy there’s no way that I’d eat it! I will pin it though. Thanks.

  59. Dianna Davis says:

    Lol these are great– I know this has to be pinned—I will never remember them all and where I found these–THis is going to be one of favorite recipes all of them. Thank you for sharing these. 🙂

  60. Tianna says:

    so many awesome ideas! Love the creepy zombie brains!

    stop by and chat ♥ http://storybookapothecary.com
    Tianna recently posted…Random Friday Favorites #49 | Fall 2015 Bucket ListMy Profile

  61. Julie S. says:

    These are creepy and totally fun 🙂 I have made those devilled egg eyes before. (No one ate them, I guess they were too creepy)

  62. Christine says:

    Oooh my gaaawwwwwd I love this so much. Not sure I could actually eat some of these but people are so freakin’ creative! I am also a total fool for Halloween. Thanks for linking up at #SaucySaturdays.
    Christine recently posted…Triple The Love Apple CakeMy Profile

  63. Jess, these are great! Thanks for contributing them to SHARE IT! Pinning… Till Saturday!
    Rose who’s busy being creative at FineCraftGuild.com recently posted…Kids Craft: Ceramic Hand DishMy Profile

  64. Julie says:

    I usually just do mouldy cakes (green colouring) and ghost meringues – these ideas are great. The kitty litter tray is my absolute favourite though – fantastically awful!
    Julie recently posted…Kitchen Art from my Nan’s RecipeMy Profile

  65. Oh wow! Interesting looking food presentation! Perfect for Halloween. So fun! Thank you for sharing with us at Friday Favorites! I’ve tweeted your post!
    Stephanie @ Casa Watkins recently posted…5 Ways to Transition Your Home For Fall with Big Lots!My Profile

  66. Heather says:

    Ha ha!! I love the graveyard taco dip! THat’s such a fun idea! I’m featuring your pin in my next Pinterest Party Link up! Thanks for stopping by and participating! Can’t wait to see ya next week!
    Heather recently posted…Weekend Giveaway Link Up!My Profile

  67. Love this! Thanks so much for joining in the fun at Thursday Favorite Things Blog Hop!

  68. Visiting again from the #PartyGalsLinky! So gross and fun! Particularly fond of the kitty litter (ew.)
    Keisha – Cupcake Wishes & Birthday Dreams recently posted…Party Gals Linky Party No. 7My Profile

  69. Erica says:

    These are so fun! thanks for sharing at #FTAF
    Erica recently posted…From the Archives Friday #7My Profile

  70. Katie V. says:

    Those are awesome, and a little gross, hahahah! I don’t know if I could eat the brains but the graveyard taco dip is adorable!
    Katie V. recently posted…TGIFF: The Spring Bouquet AppliquéMy Profile

  71. Oh my goodness, I could hardly even look at half of these recipes…let alone eat them! I’m particularly queasy when it comes to blood + food, I don’t think I could stomach these but this is a great round up for those who can! Mayybeee I’d try a few of them 😛 Thanks for linking up at Welcome Home Wednesday, I’m looking forward to reading the other posts you shared with us.
    Sam // DIY Just Cuz recently posted…Not Your Mama’s Maxi: A Guide to Sewing an Hourglass Maxi SkirtMy Profile

  72. Jamie says:

    That “Taco Dip” looks amazing!! Going to pin that to try next month! 🙂
    Jamie recently posted…Things That Bring Back Memories – “Party of Five” TV Show #MondayMemoriesMy Profile

  73. I’m always so amazed by you! This looks so fun! Pinned and tweeted. I appreciate you taking the time to party with us. I hope to see you on Monday at 7. Happy Monday! Lou Lou Girls
    Lou Lou Girls recently posted…Mickey Mouse CakeMy Profile

  74. Great round up! Thanks for sharing at the Inspiration Spotlight Party. Pinned & shared. Hope to see you again soon.
    Theresa @DearCreatives recently posted…Blogging Linky Party: Inspiration Spotlight Crafts, DIY, Recipes #Linkup Party 162My Profile

  75. sue says:

    Oh my goodness those fingers give me the creeps – so I suppose mission accomplished. I bet your Halloween Parties are fun! Thanks for sharing these ideas with us at #WednesdaysWisdom.
    sue recently posted…5 Quick Ways to Boost Your Energy LevelMy Profile

  76. chellie says:

    The human torso appetizer is awesome. Last year, we studied the human body for school, that would’ve been perfect! Thanks for linking up with from the archives friday!!

  77. These are so gross, LOL. Thanks for sharing them on the Sunday Social.
    Anjanette @mommayoung recently posted…The Sunday Social Linky Party (9/20)My Profile

  78. OMG! These totally made me say Ewwww and Grrroosss! We are having a scrapbooking event on Halloween and I loved the brains. Thanks so much for sharing at #HomeMattersParty
    Michelle James recently posted…Adding a Drop Shadow – Photoshop Elements Video 6My Profile

  79. […] the creepiest halloween food ever! […]

  80. Blanca says:

    The graveyard taco dip looks like one I can do 🙂 Thank you for linking up to The Party Gals Linky.

  81. Annie B says:

    Haha some of these are so creative. I am not sure I could handle serving the litter tray one! Great ideas. Thanks for linking up to #MakingHome
    Annie B recently posted…The Making Home Weekly Link Up #7My Profile

  82. Grace says:

    Man, I don’t know if I could eat some of those they’re so gross – especially the human torso appetizer. One year I did the witch’s fingers and my husband carved watermelon into brains which was pretty cool.
    Grace recently posted…Is the Vulnerability of Creativity Worth It?My Profile

  83. Audrey says:

    Well this certainly is a creepy list. Luckily for my squeamishness, my son is not into the creepy stuff… yet.Thanks for sharing on Creative K Kids’ Tasty Tuesdays link up. Hope to see you back next week.
    Audrey recently posted…Home Matters Linky Party #57My Profile

  84. These are SO cool!!! Thanks for joining our Fabulous Foodie Fridays party! xx

  85. What a great roundup! Thanks for sharing at the #HomeMattersParty – hope to see you again next week!
    Chelsea @ The Johnsons Plus Dog recently posted…Home Matters Linky Party #57My Profile

  86. Alice Megan says:

    Some awesome ideas I love the panacotta eye
    Alice Megan recently posted…WWI – Holiday BluesMy Profile

  87. Thank you so much for sharing your post with us at the #AnythingGoes Link Party! See you next week.
    Sandy Sandmeyer recently posted…Well Balanced WineMy Profile

  88. Robyn says:

    I know all this food is perfectly edible but I can’t help but shudder looking at them, especially the rat. I guess that means they’re perfect for halloween. Thanks for linking up with FFF. xx

  89. This is real fun roundup! I am always too chicken to make scary food… But, hey, why not?! Thank you for linking this up at SHARE IT 33. A new party will open again tonight/tomorrow and we hope to see you there again! ~ Rose
    Rose, who’s busy crafting at the FineCraftGuild recently posted…SHARE IT 34 + DIY Cheap Shoes for Women who love Trendy PumpsMy Profile

  90. […] Creepiest Halloween Food Ever by Dreaming of Leaving […]

  91. Hi Jess. Wow! These recipes certainly are creepy. Thanks so much for linking up to Thriving on Thursdays. I’m featuring this post in a Halloween round up post on my blog today. Thanks for your support.

    Anne @ Domesblissity
    Anne @ Domesblissity recently posted…Business Mamas Diploma of Business – Getting down to businessMy Profile

  92. […] Frankenstein Treats by A Sprinkle of This & That The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever by Dreaming of Leaving […]

  93. URL says:

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More: dreamingofleaving.com/2014/10/15/creepiest-halloween-food-ever/ […]

  94. […] Oh yes. – The CREEPIEST Halloween food. THIS one had me gasping!! It totally creeped me out..and made me wish we celebrated Halloween in […]

  95. […] The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever from Dreaming of Leaving, Flying Bat Silhouettes from A The Scrap Shoppe Blog, DIY HALLOWEEN […]

  96. […] If you are ready for a killer Halloween party then look to Dreaming of Leaving for some spooky and creepy foods! […]

  97. […] Creepiest Halloween Food Ever by Dreaming of Leaving […]

  98. A co worker of mine made the kitty litter cake one year. It was so much fun. It actually looks like real…well you know. This year I want to try the zombie brain rice krispie treats. Great list
    Melissa Ruddy recently posted…100 Days of Real Food:Fast and Fabulous Recipe ReviewMy Profile

  99. […] (My Life By Jess) – The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever from Dreaming of […]

  100. Such fun!! Thank you for sharing at Snickerdoodle Create~Bake~Make link party!

  101. […] Dollar Store Halloween Wreath from Smiling Notes  Jessica (My Life By Jess)  – The Creepiest Halloween Food Ever from Dreaming of leaving Gabby (Not Too Shabby Gabby)  – Mac and Cheese Soup from […]

  102. […] at Dreaming of Leaving had me howling like a werewolf with her round up of the Creepiest Halloween Food Ever. Well…howling and dry heaving. I’m sure it all tastes fantastic but some […]

Leave a reply

CommentLuv badge

1.1K Flares Facebook 0 Google+ 0 Twitter 0 Pin It Share 1.1K StumbleUpon 1 Email -- 1.1K Flares ×